Imagining a Different Past
📘 Level 3 — Past Perfect — Lesson 4

Lesson 49 was about wishes. A wish says: “I wish it had been different.”

A third conditional goes one step further. It says what would have happened if the past had been different.

If she had studied, she would have passed.
(She didn’t study. She didn’t pass.)
If + Past Perfect, would have + past participle.
Both parts are imaginary. Both are the opposite of what really happened.

Look at five more sentences:

  • If I had known, I would have called you.
  • If we had left earlier, we would have caught the train.
  • If it hadn’t rained, we would have gone to the park.
  • If he had taken the bus, he wouldn’t have been late.
  • She would have passed if she had studied.
What Really Happened

Every third conditional has a real story behind it. Find the real story first. Then say the opposite in both parts.

What really happenedThe third conditional
She didn’t study. She didn’t pass.If she had studied, she would have passed.
We left late. We were late.If we hadn’t left late, we wouldn’t have been late.
I didn’t know. I didn’t call.If I had known, I would have called.
He forgot his keys. He stood outside.If he hadn’t forgotten his keys, he wouldn’t have stood outside.
We didn’t buy tickets. We didn’t see the show.If we had bought tickets, we would have seen the show.
It rained. We stayed home.If it hadn’t rained, we wouldn’t have stayed home.

Use the same test as in lesson 49:

You didn’t do it → had done it … would have …
You did it → hadn’t done it … wouldn’t have …
Two Parts, Two Forms

A third conditional has two parts. Each part has its own form.

PartFormExample
The if-partIf + had + past participleIf she had studied
The result partwould have + past participleshe would have passed

The if-part uses the same Past Perfect as in lessons 47, 48, and 49. The result part is new: would have + the past participle.

For a negative, use hadn’t in the if-part and wouldn’t have in the result part.

  • If I hadn’t eaten so much, I wouldn’t have felt sick.
  • If she had asked me, I wouldn’t have said no.

The if-part can go first or last. Use a comma when it goes first.

If she had called, I would have waited. (comma)
I would have waited if she had called. (no comma)

For a question, start with Would + the subject + have + the past participle.

  • Would she have passed if she had studied?
  • What would you have done if you had lost your keys?
The Short Form ’d

In speech, had and would both become ’d. They sound the same. The position tells you which word it is.

If I’d known, I’d have called.
= If I had known, I would have called.

The first ’d is in the if-part. It means had. The second ’d is in the result part. It means would.

  • If we’d left earlier, we’d have caught the train.
  • If she’d studied, she’d have passed.
  • I’d have called if I’d known.

Write would have, not “would of.” The sound is “would’ve,” but the spelling is would have.

Watch Out For These
❌ Mistake 1 — Past Simple in the if-part
✗ If she studied harder, she would have passed.
✗ If we left earlier, we would have caught the train.
✓ If she had studied harder, she would have passed.
✓ If we had left earlier, we would have caught the train.
The if-part looks back at the past. Use the Past Perfect: had + the past participle.
❌ Mistake 2 — “would have” in the if-part
✗ If I would have known, I would have called.
✗ If she would have studied, she would have passed.
✓ If I had known, I would have called.
✓ If she had studied, she would have passed.
Would have goes only in the result part. The if-part uses had.
❌ Mistake 3 — Only one part is the opposite
✗ He forgot his keys and stood outside. → If he hadn’t forgotten his keys, he would have stood outside.
✗ We left late and we were late. → If we hadn’t left late, we would have been late.
✓ If he hadn’t forgotten his keys, he wouldn’t have stood outside.
✓ If we hadn’t left late, we wouldn’t have been late.
Both parts are the opposite of what really happened. Change both parts.
Try It Yourself
Exercise A — Which Form Goes in the If-Part?

Click the verb form that completes the if-part correctly.

  • 1
    If she harder, she would have passed the exam. (study)
    ✓ Correct — The if-part looks back at the past. Use the Past Perfect: had + past participle.
  • 2
    If we earlier, we would have caught the train. (leave)
    ✓ Correct — The if-part looks back at the past. Use the Past Perfect: had + past participle.
  • 3
    If I your number, I would have called you. (know)
    ✓ Correct — The if-part looks back at the past. Use the Past Perfect: had + past participle.
  • 4
    If he his keys, he wouldn’t have been locked out. (not forget)
    ✓ Correct — The if-part looks back at the past. Use the Past Perfect: had + past participle.
  • 5
    If they the earlier bus, they would have arrived on time. (take)
    ✓ Correct — The if-part looks back at the past. Use the Past Perfect: had + past participle.
  • 6
    If you me, I would have come. (tell)
    ✓ Correct — The if-part looks back at the past. Use the Past Perfect: had + past participle.
  • 7
    If it so hard, we would have gone to the park. (not rain)
    ✓ Correct — The if-part looks back at the past. Use the Past Perfect: had + past participle.
  • 8
    If she the instructions, she would have fixed it. (follow)
    ✓ Correct — The if-part looks back at the past. Use the Past Perfect: had + past participle.
Exercise B — Complete the Sentence

Type the correct verb form for the verb given.

  • 1
    If she harder, she would have passed. (study)
  • 2
    If we had left earlier, we the train. (catch)
  • 3
    If I had known, I you. (call)
  • 4
    They on time if they had taken the bus. (arrive)
  • 5
    If he the instructions, he would have fixed it. (follow)
  • 6
    She the test if she had studied. (pass)
  • 7
    If you me, I would have come. (tell)
  • 8
    We the game if we had played better. (win)
Exercise C — Make It Negative

Type the negative Past Perfect for the verb given.

  • 1
    If I so much, I wouldn’t have felt sick. (not eat)
  • 2
    If she her keys, she wouldn’t have been locked out. (not forget)
  • 3
    If we had left earlier, we late. (not be)
  • 4
    If it so hard, we would have gone out. (not rain)
  • 5
    If our team had played better, we the game. (not lose)
  • 6
    If you had told me, I the wrong answer. (not give)
  • 7
    If the shop early, we would have bought the gift. (not close)
  • 8
    If I had known the truth, I him. (not believe)
Exercise D — Write the Question

Type the missing words of speaker B’s question, using the words given.

  • 1
    A: Maria studied hard and passed the exam.
    B: if she hadn’t studied? (she / pass)
  • 2
    A: We left late and the bus was gone.
    B: the bus if you had left earlier? (you / catch)
  • 3
    A: Tom didn’t call me.
    B: What if he had called? (you / say)
  • 4
    A: They took the highway.
    B: earlier if they had taken the old road? (they / arrive)
  • 5
    A: I bought the expensive phone.
    B: What if you hadn’t bought it? (you / buy)
  • 6
    A: She quit her job.
    B: What if she hadn’t quit? (she / do)
  • 7
    A: The team lost the game.
    B: if they had practiced more? (they / win)
  • 8
    A: He forgot his keys.
    B: Where if he had remembered them? (he / go)
Exercise E — If-Part or Result Part?

Look at the position of the gap. Click the form that fits.

  • 1
    If I the answer, I would have told you.
    ✓ Correct — This is the if-part. It takes had + past participle.
  • 2
    If it had rained, we at home.
    ✓ Correct — This is the result part. It takes would have + past participle.
  • 3
    If she harder, she would have passed.
    ✓ Correct — This is the if-part. It takes had + past participle.
  • 4
    They would have won if they better.
    ✓ Correct — This is the if-part. It takes had + past participle.
  • 5
    If he had called me, I the news.
    ✓ Correct — This is the result part. It takes would have + past participle.
  • 6
    I you if I had seen you.
    ✓ Correct — This is the result part. It takes would have + past participle.
  • 7
    If we had bought tickets, we the concert.
    ✓ Correct — This is the result part. It takes would have + past participle.
  • 8
    She would have gone if she the invitation.
    ✓ Correct — This is the if-part. It takes had + past participle.
Apply What You Know

Read each question. Choose the sentence that matches.

Question 1 of 8
Select the correct sentence.
Question 2 of 8
Which sentence means: “She didn’t study, so she didn’t pass”?
Question 3 of 8
“He forgot his passport and stayed home.” Which sentence matches?
Question 4 of 8
Select the correct question.
Question 5 of 8
Select the sentence that is incorrect.
Question 6 of 8
In “If I’d known, I’d have called,” what does the first ’d mean?
Question 7 of 8
Which sentence is a wish, not a third conditional?
Question 8 of 8
Select the sentence with the correct result part.
Past Perfect: Third Conditional A third conditional imagines a different past. If + Past Perfect, would have + past participle. Both parts are the opposite of what happened.
  • If-part: if + had + past participle. Result part: would have + past participle.
  • You didn’t do it → had done … would have …
  • You did it → hadn’t done … wouldn’t have …
  • Change both parts. Both are the opposite of what happened.
  • Questions: Would + subject + have + past participle?
  • Speech: if I’d known (had), I’d have called (would). Write would have, not “would of.”